This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
Common Pitfalls Which Harm Contentious Probate Claims
Last Updated on April 22, 2026 by tanya
Common Pitfalls Which Harm Contentious Probate Claims
About Our Legal Expert: This content is produced under the oversight of Michael Jefferies, First Personal Injury Director, who brings over 30 years of legal experience.
Written by Tanya Waterworth, Digital Content Writer
Mistakes to Avoid in Inheritance Disputes
As more wills are being disputed, so is the rise in common pitfalls which harm contentious probate claims. Contentious probate refers to any dispute about a person’s estate after they have died. It covers legal challenges related to whether the will is valid, how an estate is being administered, or who is entitled to inherit. The sharp increase in disagreements over wills and inheritance issues may be due to more complex family structures, higher property values and complicated financial arrangements.
Many people may unknowingly damage their probate claims long before seeking legal advice. This can be the result of small mistakes, often made in the early days after someone dies, which can weaken or even destroy a legitimate case.
If you are considering challenging a will or defending a claim, it is vital to act quickly and strategically. This includes consulting a contentious probate solicitor who can offer an initial, free consultation to assess your case.
We partner with experienced contentious probate lawyers who also offer a range of fee structures, including ‘No Win, No Fee’ for certain cases along with other flexible funding.
Missing Critical Deadlines
One of the main pitfalls in contentious probate is running out of time. Different types of probate disputes have different time limits and some of them are extremely short.
Key deadlines include:
Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 claims – 6 months from the date of the grant of probate.
Claims for rectification of a will – 6 months from the grant.
Challenges based on fraud or forgery – no fixed time limit, but delay can severely weaken credibility.
Challenges based on undue influence, lack of capacity or want of knowledge and approval – ideally brought before the estate is distributed.
Many people delay seeking advice because they feel uncomfortable challenging a loved one’s will or they assume they have plenty of time. Unfortunately, when a key deadline passes, the court is generally reluctant to hear the claim at all.
How a solicitor helps: A specialist contentious probate solicitor can immediately identify relevant deadlines and take steps to protect your position, including registering caveats or issuing protective proceedings if needed.
Allowing the Estate to Be Distributed Too Early
Executors often begin distributing an estate before a dispute has been properly raised. Once assets have been distributed, it becomes considerably more difficult to recover them.
Many claimants mistakenly assume that “raising concerns” is enough. But in fact you must take formal steps such as entering a caveat or notifying executors in writing of an intended claim.
If you suspect wrongdoing, delay, or errors in the estate administration, you must act quickly.
How a solicitor helps: They can stop distribution by:
Entering a caveat to prevent probate being issued.
Notifying executors of an intended claim.
Applying to court for injunctions or orders if appropriate.
This ensures assets remain available for division once the dispute is resolved.
Relying on Informal Evidence and Assumptions
Many contentious probate disputes fail because the claimant may rely on informal assumptions, family conversations, or vague recollections rather than admissible evidence.
Courts in England and Wales require strong evidence, not feelings or memories.
Examples of weak evidence include:
“My relative said they would leave me the house.”
“The deceased promised we would inherit equally.”
“That can’t be their signature because it doesn’t look right.”
While these concerns may be valid, they need supporting documentation, witness statements, medical evidence, financial records, or expert reports.
How a solicitor helps: A contentious probate solicitor knows how to:
Gather proper evidence.
Obtain medical notes.
Commission expert handwriting reports.
Analyse financial transactions.
Secure witness testimony.
Without robust evidential support, even strong suspicions of wrongdoing can collapse in court.
Speaking to Other Beneficiaries Without Legal Guidance
Family discussions can easily escalate into confrontations, misunderstandings, or admissions that may damage your case later. Many people reveal too much information during emotional conversations, unintentionally weakening their legal position.
Common mistakes include:
Threatening to ‘go to court’ without proper legal advice.
Making accusations of fraud or undue influence.
Agreeing informally to settlements that are not enforceable.
Sharing potential evidence prematurely.
Sending combative emails or texts which later appear unreasonable.
Contentious probate claims are emotionally charged, and courts look unfavourably on parties who appear to be unreasonable or hostile.
How a solicitor helps:
Your solicitor can manage communications, keep discussions professional, and ensure nothing is said that could harm your case. They can also negotiate calmly and objectively, avoiding unnecessary hostility.
Assuming the Will Is Invalid Without Exploring All Grounds
People often challenge a will based on instinct alone: “It doesn’t seem right,” “It must be forged,” or “They were vulnerable.” While these instincts are sometimes justified, probate law requires specific legal grounds such as:
Lack of knowledge and approval
Clerical errors requiring rectification
Failing to identify the correct grounds or pursuing the wrong ones can waste time and money.
How a solicitor helps:
A contentious probate lawyer can quickly assess which grounds are viable, what evidence is required, and how strong your claim is before you start a claim.
Not Understanding the Costs Risks
It’s important to understand that contentious probate proceedings can be expensive with costs escalating rapidly. Courts may order a losing party to pay not only their own costs but also a portion of the other side’s. Many people underestimate this risk.
Courts may penalise parties who:
- Delay unnecessarily.
- Act unreasonably.
- Reject reasonable settlement offers.
- Pursue claims with little legal merit.
This makes early legal advice essential.
How a solicitor helps: A specialist solicitor can provide:
Clear advice on cost risks.
Guidance on funding options, such as No Win No Fee agreements
Effective strategies to encourage settlement and minimise court involvement.
Failing to Mediate or Explore Settlement
Most contentious probate claims are settled before going to court. In fact, courts expect parties to explore alternative dispute resolution such as mediation.
How a solicitor helps: Your solicitor can:
Prepare you for mediation.
Recommend skilled mediators.
Negotiate on your behalf.
Help you understand your strengths and weaknesses.
Well-managed mediation may often resolve disputes more quickly and at far lower cost than court proceedings.
Why Should You Use a Contentious Probate Solicitor?
Navigating a probate dispute without legal guidance is risky. An experienced contentious probate solicitor offers guidance, strategy, and clarity during what is often an emotionally overwhelming time.
Key benefits include:
Immediate protection of your claim: caveats, early notices, preservation orders.
Assessment of claim strength: avoiding wasted time on weak grounds.
Access to expert evidence: medical, handwriting, forensic accounting.
Strategic negotiation: ensuring discussions remain constructive.
Cost management: clear advice and structured planning.
Procedural expertise: preventing avoidable mistakes and missed deadlines.
Specialist lawyers in this field understand the complexities of will disputes, executor removal applications, inheritance claims and estate administration problems. Whether you are bringing a claim or defending one, having a contentious probate solicitor on your side significantly increases your chances of achieving a fair outcome.
Take Action Now
Contentious probate disputes are complicated, emotional and subject to time limits. Even strong claims can fail if early mistakes are made or if crucial evidence is lost. Acting promptly with the support of a specialist solicitor can give you the best chance of securing a just result.
If you believe a will is invalid, you have concerns about undue influence, or you feel you have been unfairly excluded from an estate, do not wait.
📞 Call us now on 0333 358 2345 📧 Or contact us online and we’ll call you back to arrange your free consultation.